A Lot about a Little - Dean T. Hartwell's Site
  • Home
  • Planes without Passengers
  • WTC7
  • Jury Duty
  • MOTION DISMISSED!
  • Essays
  • Testimonials
  • Contact

Presidential Campaigns Have Their Own Dialogue

7/4/2012

2 Comments

 
Picture
Throughout every recent presidential campaign, a dialogue develops in the media between the major candidates for the job.  The candidate best able to position themselves before the public takes the job.

The dialogue has its context.  Voters have a distinct perception of the most important issue, how well or how poorly the economy is doing.  And they hear reports of how wars are going.

This perception is how Ronald Reagan used the phrase “Morning in America” in his re-election campaign of 1984.  As the public already believed, rightly or wrongly, that the nation had peace and prosperity, Reagan’s dialogue was strengthened.

As a way of telling the public not to argue with success, he said of his opponent, Walter Mondale, that he “never met a tax he didn’t hike” and that he “taxes [Reagan’s] patience.”  Mondale’s response, that he was being “honest” about the need for new taxes, got lost in the dialogue.  Given the choice of a candidate who promised jobs and a candidate who promised the truth, voters as a group were conditioned to optimism and believed they could have both.

A dialogue over taxes took over the following election between Vice President George H. W. Bush and Massachusetts Governor Michael Dukakis.  Bush lacked his predecessor’s congenial manner and used issues in a more cynical way.

Bush’s dialogue included phrases such as “read my lips, no new taxes” and a name for his opponent’s state, “Taxachusetts.”  But on the issue of crime, he repeatedly named a man who had been released as part of the Massachusetts furlough program and who had then raped a woman.  Television commercials made it clear that the prisoner, Willie Horton, was a black man.

It was as if Bush was saying that the voters ought to fear a Dukakis election as crime and taxes would go up.  He also threw in Dukakis’ veto of a bill that would have made a teacher’s refusal to lead the pledge of allegiance a crime.  It was an assault on Dukakis for some of his ideas of public safety, taxes and patriotism.

Dukakis responded by explaining that a predecessor had started the furlough program and that he (Dukakis) had ended it after the Horton incident.  He attacked Bush for promising not to raise taxes (a pledge that came back to haunt Bush albeit too late to help Dukakis).  And he made it clear that he had gotten an advisory opinion about the bill on the pledge of allegiance from his state’s highest court, which told him it was unconstitutional.

The dialogue had Dukakis on the defensive even before he answered.  Bush picked issues that evoke a visceral response but would not have gotten away with selecting these issues had the economy not be understood by the public to be satisfactory.  Bush could not get re-elected because the economy had worsened over the next four years and because he had to defend his own record.

So what is in store for the election of 2012?

The economy has gone from bad in 2008 to…bad in 2012.  President Obama will talk about his health care legislation and how the Supreme Court found it to be constitutional.

Mitt Romney will have to find a new way to attack a law patterned to a good extent after a law he signed when governor of Massachusetts.  He will also have to explain what he would do differently than Obama in turning around the economy.

The burden is on Romney to find a chord that even some Democrats can agree with.  Obama has positioned himself as a somebody.  It will take a somebody to beat one.



2 Comments

The Greatest Lesson We Should Learn from 9/11

2/12/2012

0 Comments

 
_ We should learn how easily the public can be convinced of something that touches them emotionally.  Almost everyone on September 11, 2001 reported the same sense of shock about the attacks, the same sense of sadness about the victims and the same sense of anger toward the perpetrators.

We should know by now to be careful to guard our judgments about events in which our leaders may well have reason to mislead us.  Recent history has shown us a number of official lies, for example, President Lyndon Johnson’s acceptance of Israel’s explanation that it made a “mistake” in bombing the U.S.S. Liberty in 1967, President Reagan’s insistence that “we did not -- repeat did not -- trade weapons or anything else for hostages nor will we” and President George W. Bush’s persistent claim of “weapons of mass destruction” in Iraq.

We should learn the value in deciding for ourselves how to respond to false statements made by our leaders and to reason to what extent it matters.  The key is to understand why the lie is told.

President Johnson did not want to alienate the strong pro-Israeli support he had by publicly accusing Israel of acting with knowledge that it struck a United States ship.  President Reagan likely could not believe that people in his Administration would resort to a wild ploy of selling weapons to the Ayatollah in Iran.  President Bush wanted a war with Iraq and was willing to sell the idea with lies.

So why did our leaders lie about the events of 9/11?

One need only to look at the consequences of each lie told.

The naming of Osama bin Laden as the leader of the attacks gave our leaders a scapegoat that the public could focus on instead of upon our government.

The allegations of hijackers taking over airplanes and crashing them allowed our leaders to portray the attacks in an emotional, even numbing way.

The identification of passengers with their pictures convinced the public that people really died in airplane crashes.  It was again the use of emotion over facts, facts that could not support commercial airplane crashes.

The story itself serves as a psychological operation to instill fear in the public about something almost all of us have done: take an airplane flight.

The greatest lesson of all is the awareness that anything could happen in the future and that we will not likely receive any warning that our leaders are lying to us.  Our greatest gift to ourselves and to others is our ability to think for ourselves.

0 Comments

Reverse the Revolution of 1963

8/13/2010

0 Comments

 
Complaints about President Obama's foreign policy can be heard among those who voted for change from his predecessor.  But determining what to do about Guantanamo Bay, the rights of suspected terrorists and even finding ways to end the failed wars in Afghanistan and Iraq will only address symptoms of a deeper problem.

Not even a revolution will cause substantial change if no one knows the root of what harms our nation.  We should understand that we had a revolution in 1963.  It would serve us well to recall how we got from there to here:

In November of that year, several shots fired from different directions felled President John Kennedy in broad daylight in Dallas, Texas.  An innocent man, Lee Harvey Oswald, was framed for the crime and the authorities missed several leads, such as dozens of “ear” witnesses who said the fatal shot came from in front of the president’s motorcade.

Enter Lyndon Baines Johnson, sworn in next to the late president’s widow, who still had his blood on her clothes.  As soon as LBJ covered up the JFK assassination by appointing enemies of JFK to "investigate" the coup was complete.  The revolution began and has never stopped.

Johnson went on to reverse JFK’s draw down of our involvement in a war in Viet Nam.  And after using false reports of U.S. ships being fired upon in the Gulf of Tonkin to get “authority” to prosecute the war, he never looked back.  He attempted to fund social programs to fight poverty and the war.

Enter Richard Nixon who said we had to choose one or the other.  Guess which one he chose?

The war ultimately took the lives of millions of Vietnamese people along with over 58,000 of our troops.  The public found out by that time that our leaders had lied about the war thanks to the Pentagon Papers and other reports.

No matter.

Enter Jimmy Carter.  Elected after the only non-elected President, Gerald Ford, took over from Nixon, Carter said he would not lie.  But even the president who used military force least often among recent presidents got us involved in a covert war in Afghanistan.  He shipped weapons illegally through Pakistan to a group of people who fought alongside Osama bin Laden.

We had to stop the communists!

But the CIA wanted more covert action to fight the communists in Nicaragua.  Carter wouldn’t do it.  Not a problem.  The revolution continued with some new leaders.

Enter Ronald Reagan and George H.W. Bush.  Reagan was the front man who talked tough about Iran who held our people hostage.  Bush was the guy in the back room making deals with the Ayatollah by sending him weapons in exchange for a delay in the release of the hostages.

Since then, we have continued with a succession of presidents who have kept the military happy.  Bill Clinton went for Somalia and Bosnia, while George W. Bush used a false 9/11 story about terrorists as a pretext for invading Afghanistan and Iraq.  Now Obama has kept the war drums going in both nations.

People such as military generals, arms contractors, politicians, those with stock in the contractors and the idiots who wave the flag no matter what have a major hand in this problem. They make up the "War Party." Though a minority, they have conned the rest of us into accepting a new kind of war.

Instead of fighting wars that we could win or even battle to a draw (like the Korean War), we started getting involved in wars for the sake of fighting wars.


Of course that sounds like unwise policy, so:

The War Party has employed phony arguments like Tonkin and 9/11 and phony enemies like bin Laden.

They have factored the phrase "national security" into public announcements of decisions but no one ever says what it means.

They told us we had to stop the "domino effect" in Viet Nam, but even though we lost South Viet Nam, the dominos did not fall.


They told us that we had to oppose the communists who don’t believe in freedom though South Vietnamese, our allies, never held free elections during the time we occupied their nation.

They told us Saddam Hussein was an ally, then they later said he was another “Hitler.”

They have told us both China and Cuba are evil communists, but that it is OK to trade with China but not Cuba.

They have told us bin Laden did 9/11 but fail to tell us that they have never indicted him for it. 

They told us that we must be “tough on terrorists” while they traded arms to try to free them.

 

We cannot understand change without understand what got us where we are.  Ignorance of history and its consequences is far more of any enemy than President Obama or any politician could ever be.

We could say we are victims of the War Party but by tolerating them we become accomplices to their greed.   Understanding our own role in perpetuating the revolution is the first step in causing its demise.

0 Comments

    Author

    Dean Hartwell keeps pursuing the truth about those who govern us.

    Categories

    All
    9/11
    9/11
    9/11 Flights
    9/11 Flights
    9/11 Flights
    9/11 Lies
    9/11 Lies
    9/11 Myth
    9/11 Passengers
    9/11 Passengers
    9/11 Passengers
    9/11 Passengers
    9/11 Phone
    9/11 Planes
    9/11 Planes
    9/11 Planes
    9/11 Plot
    9/11 Relatives
    9/11 Truth
    9/11 Truth
    9/11 Truth
    Acars
    Addiction
    Adventist
    Adversity
    A Fans Folklore5e0914a21d
    Afp
    Agent
    Agents
    Allies
    Amazon
    American 11
    American 77
    American 77
    American Free Press
    Amnesty
    Argument
    Armed Forces
    Assassination
    Associated Press
    Atheism
    Author
    Authority
    Authors
    Barbara Olson
    Barnes And Noble
    Baseball
    Battle
    Belief
    Bible
    Bill Giltner
    Bin Laden
    Bin Laden Framed
    Bipolar
    Bipolar Disorder
    Birthers
    Blogtalkradio
    Bob Fox
    Book
    Book Review
    Books
    Broncos
    Budget
    Bullies
    Bully
    Bureaucracy
    Burley
    Bush Administration
    Calpers
    Campaign
    Campaign 2016
    Candor
    Cell Phone Calls
    Change
    Charles Giuliani
    Cheating
    Cheney
    Choice
    Christianity
    Chuck Ochelli
    Cia
    Cimino
    Circle
    City Of San Bernardino
    Cleveland
    Colin Powell
    Comments
    Communication
    Conflict
    Conformity
    Conspiracy
    Constitution
    Constructiveness
    Contract
    Conversation
    Corporations
    Country
    Court
    Critical Acclaim
    Critical Thinking
    D
    Danne Burleyb5f49f8b7f
    Danne Burley Show3cf92a4960
    David Cay Johnston
    Dead Men Talking
    Dean Hartwell
    Debate
    Decisions
    Deficit
    Democrats
    Deportation
    Depression
    Detectors
    Dialogue
    Dick Cheney
    Discussion
    Dishonesty
    Disnformation
    Distortion
    Dont Ask Dont Tell
    Drugs
    Economy
    Election 2000
    Empowerment
    Enemies
    Error
    Euphemism
    Evidence
    Facts
    Facts Talk
    Fair Elections
    Faith
    Fakery
    Fantasy Football
    Fate
    Fear
    Fetzer
    Flight 11
    Flight 175
    Flight 77
    Flight 93
    Flights
    Football
    Footnotes
    Foreign Policy
    Free Agency
    Freedom
    Free Will
    Fuqua
    Future
    Game
    Gatekeepers
    Gay Rights
    Gays
    Gingrich
    God
    Gop
    Government
    Government Lies
    Government Responsiveness
    Grand Chessboard
    Guardian
    Gumshoe News
    Gun Control
    Gun Rights
    Happiness
    Hartwell
    Hijackers
    History
    Hoax
    Homophobia
    Hope
    Hypocrisy
    Identity
    Idolotry
    Illegal Immigration
    Immaculate Reception
    Immigration
    Infiltration
    Inlaws4243aba70b
    Innocence
    Integrity
    Intel Hub
    Intelligence
    Internet
    Interview
    Interviews
    Intuition
    Irancontra8ce74f07fb
    Isolation
    Issues
    Jack Tatum
    Jesus
    Jfk
    Jfk Assassination
    Jim Fetzer
    Jim Mason
    Jim Viken
    Joe Paterno
    John Anderson
    John B Anderson4f095ea31b
    John Madden
    July 15
    Juror
    Jury
    Jury Duty
    Justice
    Kennedy
    Kennedys
    Ken Stabler
    Killtown
    Kindle
    Kohan V Nbc
    Law
    Lawsuit
    Leaders
    Leadership
    Lee Harvey Oswald
    Lee Oswald
    Lessons
    Liaison
    Lies
    Life
    Lisa Jefferson
    Logic
    Loyalty
    Lying
    Malaysian Flight
    Manipulators
    Mary W Maxwell
    Mayor White
    Mcgreal
    Media
    Memoirs
    Mental Illness
    Mh370
    Military
    Mirsch
    Mistakes
    Modern Life
    Morality
    Movie
    Myth
    Mythology
    Nation
    Nationalism
    Nbc
    Needs
    New Media
    Newt Gingrich
    Nfl
    Nixon
    No Hijackers
    No Hijackings
    No Holding Back
    No Plane
    No Planers
    No Planes
    Oakland Raiders
    Obama
    Observations
    Occupy Wall Street
    Ochelli
    October Surprise
    Official Theories
    Olson
    Oped News
    Osama
    Osama Bin Laden
    Oswald
    Parole
    Passengers
    Paterno
    Patriotism
    Peace
    Penn State
    Pension
    Pentagon
    People
    Permanent War
    Perpetual War
    Pers
    Personal
    Persuasion
    Petition
    Philosophy
    Pictures
    Pilots For 911 Truth5753843a5f
    Planers
    Planes
    Planes Without Passengers
    Planes-without-passengers
    Planted Evidence
    Pledge Of Allegiance
    Podcast
    Policy
    Politicians
    Politics
    Power
    Praise
    Presidents
    Public
    Public Policy
    Question
    Questions
    Radio
    Raiders
    Ramona Rees
    Reagan
    Real Deal
    Reason
    Recommend
    Records
    Relatives
    Religion
    Republican Party
    Republicans
    Researchers
    Responsibility
    Resurrection
    Review
    Reviews
    Revolution
    Rfk
    Righteousness
    Rights
    Risk
    Robert Kennedy
    Romney
    Ronald Reagan
    Rules
    Rumors Fly
    Samesex Marriage05ed85f18c
    San Bernardino
    Satire
    Scams
    Scapegoats
    Script
    Secrecy
    Secret
    Self Help
    Selfhelp1a7d6cf1cb
    Selfhelp930f0ee660
    Shanksville
    Shepard
    Show
    Sirhan
    Sites
    Solutions
    Stabler
    Story
    St Peter64b59c8f07
    St Peters Choicef4a5414f38
    Strategy
    Summers
    Super Bowl
    Super Bowl Xiv
    Swan
    Taxes
    Team Sports
    Tea Party
    Technology
    Ted Olson
    Terrorism
    The Detectors
    The Detectors Featuring Dean Hartwell
    The Ochelli Effect
    Theories
    Thurman Munson
    Time Management
    Todd Beamer
    Tolerance
    Trump
    Trust
    Truth
    Type I
    Type Ii
    United
    United 175
    United-175
    United 93
    United-93
    Values
    Vancouver Hearings
    Video Fakery
    Voice
    Voters
    Wants
    War
    War On Terror
    War Party
    Was 9/11 A Movie?
    Watergate
    Will And Grace Case
    World Series
    Wrong
    Youtube
    You Tube

    Archives

    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    December 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    April 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    April 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012
    November 2012
    October 2012
    September 2012
    August 2012
    July 2012
    June 2012
    May 2012
    April 2012
    March 2012
    February 2012
    January 2012
    December 2011
    November 2011
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    July 2011
    June 2011
    May 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    February 2011
    January 2011
    December 2010
    November 2010
    October 2010
    August 2010
    July 2010
    June 2010
    May 2010
    April 2010
    March 2010
    February 2010
    January 2010

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.